The
A monthly cookie surprise you didn’t know you needed... but won’t want to miss.
Fresh, handcrafted cookies. New flavors. A little extra joy delivered each month. Join Aunt Jenny Jenn’s Kitchen for a sweet subscription experience made for cookie lovers in Forest Hill, Maryland and across Harford County.
- 🍪 New monthly flavors
- 🎁 Giftable subscription option
- 📍 Forest Hill pickup
- 🔥 Limited member spots
What Is The Cookie Crew Club?
The Cookie Crew Club is our monthly mystery cookie experience
The Cookie Crew Club is our monthly mystery cookie experience created for people who love trying new flavors, treating themselves, and having something sweet to look forward to.
Each month, you’ll receive a curated set of cookies made fresh in our kitchen, with flavors and designs that change every time.
No repeats. No boring boxes. Just something fun,
new, and delicious.
What Is The Cookie Crew Club?
What You Get Each Month
Choose your cookie experience
The Sweet Treat Box (3 Cookies)
Perfect for a personal treat or a little monthly pick-me-up.
✔ 3 handcrafted cookies
✔ New flavors each month
✔ Designed and decorated by hand
Just enough to make your month sweeter.
The Cookie Lover Box (6 Cookies)
For sharing… or not
✔ 6 handcrafted cookies
✔ Monthly rotating flavors & designs
✔ Perfect for families or gifting
Because one (or three) is never enough.
Perfect For Gifting
Looking for a unique gift? The Cookie Crew Club makes such a thoughtful surprise for birthdays, new moms, friends, teachers, or really anyone who loves cookies. It’s one of those gifts that feels personal, a little unexpected, and keeps showing up with something sweet to enjoy long after the moment has passed.
More Than Just a Cookie Subscription
At Aunt Jenny Jenn’s Kitchen, every cookie is
✔ Made fresh, never mass produced
✔ Hand-decorated with care
✔ Created with intention and heart
✔ Prayed over before it ever reaches you
This isn’t a factory box of cookies…
it’s something made for you.
Why You’ll Love Being In The Crew
✔ You always have something to look forward to
✔ You get exclusive, limited flavors
✔ It feels like a little gift to yourself every month
✔ No need to think, it just shows up ready to enjoy
It’s not just cookies… it’s a monthly moment.
How The Cookie Crew Club Works
Step 1
Join the Cookie Crew
Choose your box (3 or 6 cookies) and secure your spot.
Step 2
Get Excited
Each box features surprise flavors and designs you won’t find anywhere e
Step 3
Open & enjoy
Your cookies are ready for pickup fresh, beautiful, and ready to be devoured.
Simple, fun, and always worth it.
Limited Spots Available Each Month
Because everything is made by hand and in small batches, we only open a limited number of Cookie Crew spots each month.
Once they’re full they’re full.
Don’t wait until next month to wish you joined.
Local Pickup in Forest Hill, Maryland
All Cookie Crew boxes are available for local pickup in Forest Hill, MD.
We proudly serve Bel Air and surrounding Harford County areas.
Join The Kitchen Crew
If you’ve ever taken a bite of a cookie and said…
‘OH WOW’
You’re one of us.
Welcome to the Kitchen Crew.
Sign up to receive exclusive offers, sweet surprises, and the latest news about local events and what’s happening here at Aunt Jenny Jenn’s Kitchen.
Ready to Order Cookies That Actually Wow People?
Whether you’re celebrating something big or just want something sweet done right we’ve got you.
Order now and make your next moment unforgettable.
Loved By Cookie Lovers in Forest Hill & Beyond
From custom sugar cookies to beautifully decorated event treats, customers keep coming back for cookies that look incredible, taste even better, and make every occasion feel extra special.
Sugar Cookies
I first had the sugar cookies at my baby shower and they were so good, not too sweet and absolutely adorable. I knew I then wanted them for my son’s birthday party. They were just what I wanted for the theme and color. They will not last long. Not to mention when I went to pick them up, Jenn was so kind and lovely. I would recommend Jenn to anyone and I will think of her and her baked goods for future events.
Amazing
I am so happy with the creativity and taste of the cookies I received. The baker is a ray of sunshine, such a delightful friendly girl.
The Best Cookies
The best cookies I have ever had!!!
Perfection!!!
I have ordered from Jenny Jenn's Kitchen three times now, and every single time she knocks it out of the park! The cookies are artistic perfection and delicious. Her cupcakes are amazing too. She never misses!!
Beautiful & Delicious!
I placed a last minute order for 2 dozen back to school cookies recently. Jenn was so accommodating and the cookies looked just as pictured. They were beautifully decorated and tasted so good I kept a few for myself. Definitely a repeat customer. I already ordered 3 dozen for a September event.
Why Customers Come Back
Customers consistently mention the same things: beautiful decorated cookies, amazing taste, thoughtful service, and a baker who truly cares. That combination is what turns first-time orders into repeat customers.
Serving Forest Hill, Maryland & Surrounding Areas
We proudly serve Forest Hill, Bel Air, and the greater Harford County area with custom cookies made fresh to order.
If you're searching for custom cookies near you, you're in the right place.
