Choose Your Monthly Box

Pick Your Kitchen Crew Subscription

Choose your Kitchen Crew Club subscription box and get a fresh, hand-crafted cookie drop every month. Each box is baked in Forest Hill, Maryland with rotating flavors, creative designs, and small-batch attention to detail.

🍪 6 cookies — $25
🍪 Baker’s dozen — $45
🌾 Gluten-free add-on — +$10
📦 Flat $10 shipping (Maryland only)

Subscriptions are available for Maryland orders only. Due to cottage food laws, orders cannot be shipped out of state. Boxes ship on the 15th of each month.

Cookie subscription boxes from Aunt Jenny Jenn’s Kitchen in Maryland

Monthly Cookie Drops

Small batch, fresh, and made to give you something to look forward to every month.

ORDER YOUR COOKIE SUBSCRIPTION BOX Select your cookie subscription below

Shipping

Payment

ItemQuantityPrice

6 Count Mystery Cookie Club ** Pick up only **

$25 per month

A little box of something sweet just for you.

Each month, you’ll receive 6 hand-crafted cookies featuring rotating flavors and custom designs. No two boxes are the same, which is what makes it fun.

Perfect if you want a treat without the commitment of a full dozen.

✔ 6 cookies per month ✔ Mystery flavors + designs ✔ Freshly baked + carefully packaged

📦 Ships on the 15th of every month

1

$25.00

6 Count Mystery Cookie Club **Shipped within MD ONLY**

$35 per month

A little box of something sweet just for you.

Each month, you’ll receive 6 hand-crafted cookies featuring rotating flavors and custom designs. No two boxes are the same, which is what makes it fun.

Perfect if you want a treat without the commitment of a full dozen.

✔ 6 cookies per month ✔ Mystery flavors + designs ✔ Freshly baked + carefully packaged

📦 Ships on the 15th of every month

**Shipped within MD ONLY**

1

$35.00

12 Count Mystery Cookie Club ** Pick up only **

$45 per month

This one’s for the real cookie lovers.

Each month, you’ll get a full dozen cookies fresh, creative, and made to feel a little extra special.

Share them… or keep them all. No pressure.

✔ 12 cookies per month ✔ Monthly rotating flavors ✔ Hand-crafted + custom designs

📦 Ships on the 15th of every month

P.S. They freeze very well for a few months!

1

$45.00

12 Count Mystery Cookie Club **Shipped within MD ONLY**

$55 per month

This one’s for the real cookie lovers.

Each month, you’ll get a full dozen cookies fresh, creative, and made to feel a little extra special.

Share them… or keep them all. No pressure.

✔ 12 cookies per month ✔ Monthly rotating flavors ✔ Hand-crafted + custom designs

📦 Ships on the 15th of every month

**Shipped within MD ONLY**

P.S. They freeze very well for a few months!

1

$55.00

12 Count Gluten-Free Mystery Cookie Club ** Pick up only **

$55 per month

Gluten-free shouldn’t feel like a downgrade… and here, it doesn’t.

Each month, you’ll receive 12 gluten-free cookies that are just as soft, flavorful, and thoughtfully made as everything else in the kitchen.

✔ 12 gluten-free cookies ✔ Rotating flavors + designs ✔ Baked with care and intention

📦 Ships on the 15th of every month

1

$55.00

12 Count Gluten-Free **Shipped within MD ONLY**

$65 per month

Gluten-free shouldn’t feel like a downgrade… and here, it doesn’t.

Each month, you’ll receive 12 gluten-free cookies that are just as soft, flavorful, and thoughtfully made as everything else in the kitchen.

✔ 12 gluten-free cookies ✔ Rotating flavors + designs ✔ Baked with care and intention

Include $10 shipping fee

📦 Ships on the 15th of every month

1

$65.00

Order Summary

ItemQuantityAmount

6 Count Mystery Cookie Club ** Pick up only **1$ 25.00

Order Total

$0.00

5-Star Service

Aunt Jenny Jenn’s Kitchen

Forest Hill, MD

★★★★★

Customers consistently mention the same things: beautiful decorated cookies, amazing taste, thoughtful service, and a baker who truly cares. That combination is what turns first-time orders into repeat customers.

Browse Cookie Collection

Cookie Subscription Questions

Everything you need to know about the Kitchen Crew Club monthly subscription.

What is the Kitchen Crew Club? ⌄

The Kitchen Crew Club is a monthly cookie subscription where you receive a fresh batch of hand-crafted cookies with rotating flavors and creative designs delivered or ready for pickup each month.

When do subscription boxes ship each month? ⌄

All subscription boxes ship on the 15th of each month. This ensures consistent delivery timing and fresh batches for every Kitchen Crew member.

Can I choose the cookie flavors each month? ⌄

No. Each box is a mystery selection with rotating flavors and designs. That is part of the fun and what makes each month feel like a surprise.

What subscription options are available? ⌄

You can choose between 6-count and 12-count boxes, with pickup or Maryland shipping options. Gluten-free versions are also available for select subscriptions.

Can I cancel or pause my subscription? ⌄

Yes. You can manage your subscription by canceling or pausing before the next billing cycle. Changes must be made before your next monthly charge to take effect.

Do you ship subscription boxes outside of Maryland? ⌄

No. Due to Maryland cottage food laws, all subscription boxes are limited to Maryland only for shipping or local pickup.

How fresh are the cookies when they arrive? ⌄

Cookies are baked fresh and heat-sealed before shipping or pickup. They stay fresh for up to 2 weeks at room temperature when kept sealed.

Can I freeze my subscription cookies? ⌄

Yes. Our heat-sealed cookies stay fresh for up to 2 weeks at room temperature. Do not refrigerate. To freeze, place them in a freezer-safe container for up to 3 months. Thaw at room temperature and allow condensation to evaporate before opening.

Do you offer gluten-free subscription options? ⌄

Yes. Gluten-free subscription boxes are available using dedicated gluten-free ingredients and careful preparation practices. These options are clearly listed when selecting your plan.

Is the Kitchen Crew Club worth it compared to ordering individually? ⌄

Yes. The subscription gives you a consistent monthly treat, access to rotating flavors, and a surprise element without needing to reorder each time.

Proudly Serving Forest Hill, Maryland & Surrounding Areas

We proudly serve Forest Hill, Bel Air, Fallston, Abingdon, and Jarrettsville with custom cookies made fresh to order. If you're searching for custom cookies near you in Harford County, you're in the right place.

Forest Hill, MD Bel Air, MD Fallston, MD Abingdon, MD Jarrettsville, MD Harford County